• کوردی
  • Login
Thursday, May 15, 2025
Chawy Kurd
No Result
View All Result
English
کوردی
  • Home
  • Opinions
    Three-dimensional reaction

    Three-dimensional reaction

  • Analysis
    Smart glasses

    Smart glasses

    What is happening in Gaza is genocide?

    What is happening in Gaza is genocide?

    Concept of Humanitarian Intervention and Decision 688

    Concept of Humanitarian Intervention and Decision 688

    How will Europeans cope with Trump’s policies?

    How will Europeans cope with Trump’s policies?

    The impact of the new US administration on the end of the Russian-Ukrainian war

    The impact of the new US administration on the end of the Russian-Ukrainian war

    Is Iran’s Regime About to Go the Way of Syria’s?

    Is Iran’s Regime About to Go the Way of Syria’s?

    Post-Liberalism: Trumpism and the Rise of Economic Nationalism

    Post-Liberalism: Trumpism and the Rise of Economic Nationalism

    Lessons from German statehood and development for Kurdistan

    Lessons from German statehood and development for Kurdistan

    Israel controls Syria’s water resources

    Israel controls Syria’s water resources

  • Economy
    Economics and Mental Health

    Economics and Mental Health

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part Two and Final

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    An autonomous car

    An autonomous car

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

    The Israeli-Hamas war, its rapid effects on energy

    The Israeli-Hamas war, its rapid effects on energy

  • Nation & State building

    A Brief History of NuRoj, Kurdish New Year — Newroz: second and final part

    Spiritual Revival of the Forgotten Traditions of NuRoj- Part One

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

    Referendum and the awareness of independence of a stateless nation

    Referendum and the awareness of independence of a stateless nation

    Philosophy of Environmental Ethics

    Philosophy of Environmental Ethics

  • National Security
    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (3) Last part

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (2)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

  • Soft Power
    • All
    • Cinema
    • Culture and Human building
    • Literature and Art
    • Thought
    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    9 novels that changed the world

    9 novels that changed the world

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    The role of women in political participation

    The role of women in political participation

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    The Trees also speak

    The Trees also speak

    Where Loneliness can lead?

    Where Loneliness can lead?

    The Danger of Missyar marriage on society

    The Danger of Missyar marriage on society

    • Media Research
    • Culture & Human building
    • Thought
    • Literature & Art
    • Cinema
  • Kurds In Others Eyes
    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Northern Iraq

    Northern Iraq

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

  • Interview
    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

  • Home
  • Opinions
    Three-dimensional reaction

    Three-dimensional reaction

  • Analysis
    Smart glasses

    Smart glasses

    What is happening in Gaza is genocide?

    What is happening in Gaza is genocide?

    Concept of Humanitarian Intervention and Decision 688

    Concept of Humanitarian Intervention and Decision 688

    How will Europeans cope with Trump’s policies?

    How will Europeans cope with Trump’s policies?

    The impact of the new US administration on the end of the Russian-Ukrainian war

    The impact of the new US administration on the end of the Russian-Ukrainian war

    Is Iran’s Regime About to Go the Way of Syria’s?

    Is Iran’s Regime About to Go the Way of Syria’s?

    Post-Liberalism: Trumpism and the Rise of Economic Nationalism

    Post-Liberalism: Trumpism and the Rise of Economic Nationalism

    Lessons from German statehood and development for Kurdistan

    Lessons from German statehood and development for Kurdistan

    Israel controls Syria’s water resources

    Israel controls Syria’s water resources

  • Economy
    Economics and Mental Health

    Economics and Mental Health

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part Two and Final

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    An autonomous car

    An autonomous car

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

    The Israeli-Hamas war, its rapid effects on energy

    The Israeli-Hamas war, its rapid effects on energy

  • Nation & State building

    A Brief History of NuRoj, Kurdish New Year — Newroz: second and final part

    Spiritual Revival of the Forgotten Traditions of NuRoj- Part One

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

    Referendum and the awareness of independence of a stateless nation

    Referendum and the awareness of independence of a stateless nation

    Philosophy of Environmental Ethics

    Philosophy of Environmental Ethics

  • National Security
    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (3) Last part

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (2)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

  • Soft Power
    • All
    • Cinema
    • Culture and Human building
    • Literature and Art
    • Thought
    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    9 novels that changed the world

    9 novels that changed the world

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    The role of women in political participation

    The role of women in political participation

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    The Trees also speak

    The Trees also speak

    Where Loneliness can lead?

    Where Loneliness can lead?

    The Danger of Missyar marriage on society

    The Danger of Missyar marriage on society

    • Media Research
    • Culture & Human building
    • Thought
    • Literature & Art
    • Cinema
  • Kurds In Others Eyes
    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Northern Iraq

    Northern Iraq

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

  • Interview
    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

Chawy Kurd
No Result
View All Result
Home Analysis

The War in Ukraine Is a Colonial War (1)

As the philosopher Frantz Fanon argued, colonizers see themselves as actors with purpose, and the colonized as instruments to realize the imperial vision.

Translation Unit by Translation Unit
January 27, 2023
in Analysis
0 0
A A
The War in Ukraine Is a Colonial War (1)
0
SHARES
8
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
0 0
A A

When Vladimir Putin denies the reality of the Ukrainian state, he is speaking the familiar language of empire. For five hundred years, European conquerors called the societies that they encountered “tribes,” treating them as incapable of governing themselves. As we see in the ruins of Ukrainian cities, and in the Russian practice of mass killing, rape, and deportation, the claim that a nation does not exist is the rhetorical preparation for destroying it.

Empire’s story divides subjects from objects. As the philosopher Frantz Fanon argued, colonizers see themselves as actors with purpose, and the colonized as instruments to realize the imperial vision. Putin took a pronounced colonial turn when returning to the Presidency a decade ago. In 2012, he described Russia as a “state-civilization,” which by its nature absorbed smaller cultures such as Ukraine’s. The next year, he claimed that Russians and Ukrainians were joined in “spiritual unity.” In a long essay on “historical unity,” published last July, he argued that Ukraine and Russia were a single country, bound by a shared origin. His vision is of a broken world that must be restored through violence. Russia becomes itself only by annihilating Ukraine.

As the objects of this rhetoric, and of the war of destruction that it sanctions, Ukrainians grasp all of this. Ukraine does have a history, of course, and Ukrainians do constitute a nation. But empire enforces objectification on the periphery and amnesia at the center. Thus modern Russian imperialism includes memory laws that forbid serious discussion of the Soviet past. It is illegal for Russians to apply the word “war” to the invasion of Ukraine. It is also illegal to say that Stalin began the Second World War as Hitler’s ally, and used much the same justification to attack Poland as Putin is using to attack Ukraine. When the invasion began, in February, Russian publishers were ordered to purge mentions of Ukraine from textbooks.

Faced with the Kremlin’s official mixture of fantasy and taboo, the temptation is to prove the opposite: that it is Ukraine rather than Russia that is eternal, that it is Ukrainians, not Russians, who are always right, and so on. Yet Ukrainian history gives us something more interesting than a mere counter-narrative to empire. We can find Ukrainian national feeling at a very early date. In contemporary Ukraine, though, the nation is not so much anti-colonial, a rejection of a particular imperial power, as post-colonial, the creation of something new.

Southern Ukraine, where Russian troops are now besieging cities and bombing hospitals, was well known to the ancients. In the founding myth of Athens, the goddess Athena gives the city the gift of the olive tree. In fact, the city could grow olives only because it imported grain from ports on the Black Sea coast. The Greeks knew the coast, but not the hinterland, where they imagined mythical creatures guarding fields of gold and ambrosia. Here already was a colonial view of Ukraine: a land of fantasy, where those who take have the right to dream.

The city of Kyiv did not exist in ancient times, but it is very old—about half a millennium older than Moscow. It was probably founded in the sixth or seventh century, north of any territory seen by Greeks or controlled by Romans. Islam was advancing, and Christianity was becoming European. The Western Roman Empire had fallen, leaving a form of Christianity subordinate to a pope. The Eastern (Byzantine) Empire remained, directing what we now call the Orthodox Church. As Rome and Constantinople competed for converts, peoples east of Kyiv converted to Islam. Kyivans spoke a Slavic language that had no writing system, and practiced a paganism without idols or temples.

Putin’s vision of “unity” relates to a baptism that took place in this setting. In the ninth century, a group of Vikings known as the Rus arrived in Kyiv. Seeking a southbound route for their slave trade, they found the Dnipro River, which runs through the city. Their chieftains then fought over a patchwork of territories in what is now Ukraine, Belarus, and the northeast of Russia—with Kyiv always as the prize. In the late tenth century, a Viking named Valdemar took the city, with the help of a Scandinavian army. He initially governed as a pagan. But, around 987, when the Byzantines faced an internal revolt, he sensed an opportunity. He came to the emperor’s aid, and received his sister’s hand in marriage. In the process, Valdemar converted to Christianity.

Putin claims that this messy sequence of events reveals the will of God to bind Russia and Ukraine forever. The will of God is easy to misunderstand; in any case, modern nations did not exist at the time, and the words “Russia” and “Ukraine” had no meaning. Valdemar was typical of the pagan Eastern European rulers of his day, considering multiple monotheistic options before choosing the one that made the most strategic sense. The word “Rus” no longer meant Viking slavers but a Christian polity. Its ruling family now intermarried with others, and the local people were treated as subjects to be taxed rather than as bodies to be sold.

Yet no rule defined who would take power after a Kyivan ruler’s death. Valdemar took a Byzantine princess as his wife, but he had a half a dozen others, not to mention a harem of hundreds of women. When he died in 1015, he had imprisoned one of his sons, Sviatopolk, and was making war upon another, Yaroslav. Sviatopolk was freed after his father’s death, and killed three of his brothers, but he was defeated on the battlefield by Yaroslav. Other sons entered the fray, and Yaroslav didn’t rule alone until 1036. The succession had taken twenty-one years. At least ten other sons of Valdemar had died in the meantime.

These events do not reveal a timeless empire, as Putin claims. But they do suggest the importance of a succession principle, a theme very important in Ukrainian-Russian relations today. The Ukrainian transliteration of “Valdemar” is “Volodymyr,” the name of Ukraine’s President. In Ukraine, power is transferred through democratic elections: when Volodymyr Zelensky won the 2019 Presidential election, the sitting President accepted defeat. The Russian transliteration of the same name is “Vladimir.” Russia is brittle: it has no succession principle, and it’s unclear what will happen when Vladimir Putin dies or is forced from power. The pressure of mortality confirms the imperial thinking. An aging tyrant, obsessed by his legacy, seizes upon a lofty illusion that seems to confer immortality: the “unity” of Russia and Ukraine.

In the Icelandic sagas, Yaroslav is remembered as the Lame; in Eastern Europe, he is the Wise, the giver of laws. Yet he did not solve the problem of succession. Following his reign, the lands around Kyiv fragmented again and again. In 1240, the city fell to the Mongols; later, most of old Rus was claimed by the Grand Duchy of Lithuania, then the largest state in Europe. Lithuania borrowed from Kyiv a grammar of politics, as well as a good deal of law. For a couple of centuries, its grand dukes also ruled Poland. But, in 1569, after the Lithuanian dynasty died out, a Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth was formalized, and the territories of Ukraine were placed under Polish jurisdiction.

This was a crucial change. After 1569, Kyiv was no longer a source of law but an object of it—the archetypal colonial situation. It was colonization that set off Ukraine from the former territories of Rus, and its manner generated qualities still visible today: suspicion of the central state, organization in crisis, and the notion of freedom as self-expression, despite a powerful neighbor.

During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, all the forces of Europe’s globalization seemed to bear down on Ukraine. Polish colonization resembled and in some measure enabled the European colonization of the wider world. Polish nobles introduced land-management practices—along with land managers, most of whom were Jewish—that allowed the establishment of profitable plantations. Local Ukrainian warlords rushed to imitate the system, and adopted elements of Polish culture, including Western Christianity and the Polish language. In an age of discovery, enserfed peasants labored for a world market.

Ukraine’s colonization coincided with the Renaissance, and with a spectacular flowering of Polish culture. Like other Renaissance thinkers, Polish scholars in Ukraine resuscitated ancient knowledge, and sometimes overturned it. It was a Pole, Copernicus, who undid the legacy of Ptolemy’s “Almagest” and confirmed that the Earth orbits the sun. It was another Pole, Maciej of Miechów, who corrected Ptolemy’s “Geography,” clearing Ukrainian maps of gold and ambrosia. As in ancient times, however, the tilling of the black earth enabled tremendous wealth, raising the question of why those who labored and those who profited experienced such different fates.

The Renaissance considered questions of identity through language. Across Europe, there was a debate as to whether Latin, now revived, was sufficient for the culture, or whether vernacular spoken languages should be elevated for the task. In the early fourteenth century, Dante answered this question in favor of Italian; English, French, Spanish, and Polish writers created other literary languages by codifying local vernaculars. In Ukraine, literary Polish emerged victorious over the Ukrainian vernacular, becoming the language of the commercial and intellectual élite. In a way, this was typical: Polish was a modern language, like English or Italian. But it was not the local language in Ukraine. Ukraine’s answer to the language question was deeply colonial, whereas in the rest of Europe it could be seen as broadly democratic.

The Reformation brought a similar result: local élites converted to Protestantism and then to Roman Catholicism, alienating them further from an Orthodox population. The convergence of colonization, the Renaissance, and the Reformation was specific to Ukraine. By the sixteen-forties, the few large landholders generally spoke Polish and were Catholic, and those who worked for them spoke Ukrainian and were Orthodox. Globalization had generated differences and inequalities that pushed the people to rebellion.

Ukrainians on the battlefield today rely on no fantasy of the past to counter Putin’s. If there is a precursor that matters to them, it is the Cossacks, a group of free people who lived on the far reaches of the Ukrainian steppe, making their fortress on an island in the middle of the Dnipro. Having escaped the Polish system of landowners and peasants, they could choose to be “registered Cossacks,” paid for their service in the Polish Army. Still, they were not citizens, and more of them wished to be registered than the Polish-Lithuanian parliament would allow.

The rebellion began in 1648, when an influential Cossack, Bohdan Khmelnytsky, saw his lands seized and his son attacked by a Polish noble. Finding himself beyond the protection of the law, Khmelnytsky turned his fellow-Cossacks toward revolt against the Polish-speaking, Roman Catholic magnates who dominated Ukraine. The accumulated cultural, religious, and economic grievances of the people quickly transformed the revolt into something very much like an anti-colonial uprising, with violence directed not only against the private armies of the magnates but against Poles and Jews generally. The magnates carried out reprisals against peasants and Cossacks, impaling them on stakes. The Polish-Lithuanian cavalry fought what had been their own Cossack infantry. Each side knew the other very well.

In 1651, the Cossacks, realizing that they needed help, turned to an Eastern power, Muscovy, about which they knew little. When Kyivan Rus had collapsed, most of its lands had been absorbed by Lithuania, but some of its northeastern territories remained under the dominion of a Mongol successor state. There, in a new city called Moscow, leaders known as tsars had begun an extraordinary period of territorial expansion, extending their realm into northern Asia. In 1648, the year that the Cossack uprising began, a Muscovite explorer reached the Pacific Ocean.

By Timothy Synder

The New Yorker

Previous Post

Chawy Kurd Center visits the Chinese Consulate.

Next Post

The War in Ukraine Is a Colonial War (2) Last Part

Translation Unit

Translation Unit

The translation unit of Chawy Kurd center for political developments include of several expert translators from international languages who translate articles into Kurdish.

Related Posts

Smart glasses
Analysis

Smart glasses

April 29, 2025
14
What is happening in Gaza is genocide?
Analysis

What is happening in Gaza is genocide?

April 13, 2025
18
Concept of Humanitarian Intervention and Decision 688
Analysis

Concept of Humanitarian Intervention and Decision 688

April 5, 2025
23

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

January 2023
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
« Nov   Feb »

Aa

0 0
A A
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advisors Board
  • Sponsors Board

2024 - 2022 © CHKurd - WordPress theme by ChawyKurd

No Result
View All Result
  • کوردی
  • Home
  • Opinions
  • Analysis
  • Economy
  • Nation & State building
  • National Security
  • Soft Power
    • Media Research
    • Culture & Human building
    • Thought
    • Literature & Art
    • Cinema
  • Kurds In Others Eyes
  • Interview

2024 - 2022 © CHKurd - WordPress theme by ChawyKurd

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist