• کوردی
  • Login
Friday, July 11, 2025
Chawy Kurd
No Result
View All Result
English
کوردی
  • Home
  • Opinions
    The Impact of China’s Belt and Road Initiative on the Kurdistan Region: Opportunities and Challenges

    The Impact of China’s Belt and Road Initiative on the Kurdistan Region: Opportunities and Challenges

    From Threat to Real War: The Iran–Israel Conflict and Kurdistan’s Strategic dilemma

    From Threat to Real War: The Iran–Israel Conflict and Kurdistan’s Strategic dilemma

    Three-dimensional reaction

    Three-dimensional reaction

  • Analysis
    From Sword to Drone

    From Sword to Drone

    Word and Power

    Word and Power

    The most prominent US military bases in the Middle East

    The most prominent US military bases in the Middle East

    The fiftieth session of G7; Consequences and challenges

    The fiftieth session of G7; Consequences and challenges

    Kurdish Cause in the Middle East seems Positive

    Kurdish Cause in the Middle East seems Positive

    The Right of the Kurdistan Region to Own and Manage the Energy Sector

    The Right of the Kurdistan Region to Own and Manage the Energy Sector

    Trumpism and the wave of return to the nation-state

    Trumpism and the wave of return to the nation-state

    Iraqi Arab Summit; Identity problems between ethnic and religious depths

    Iraqi Arab Summit; Identity problems between ethnic and religious depths

    Iraq is the land of dictators and the land of mass graves

    Iraq is the land of dictators and the land of mass graves

  • Economy
    The Influence of Kurdish Rugs, Textiles, and Jewelry in International Markets and Their Representation of Cultural Identity

    The Influence of Kurdish Rugs, Textiles, and Jewelry in International Markets and Their Representation of Cultural Identity

    Economics and Mental Health

    Economics and Mental Health

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part Two and Final

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    An autonomous car

    An autonomous car

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

  • Nation & State building
    Tobzawa Millie Camp of Anfal Victims

    Tobzawa Millie Camp of Anfal Victims

    In a memory of the Sykes-Picot Agreement and destiny of Kurds

    In a memory of the Sykes-Picot Agreement and destiny of Kurds

    A Brief History of NuRoj, Kurdish New Year — Newroz: second and final part

    Spiritual Revival of the Forgotten Traditions of NuRoj- Part One

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

  • National Security
    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (3) Last part

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (2)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

  • Soft Power
    • All
    • Cinema
    • Culture and Human building
    • Literature and Art
    • Thought
    Word and Power

    Word and Power

    Historical Sociology

    Historical Sociology

    Can a historian be impartial?

    Can a historian be impartial?

    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    9 novels that changed the world

    9 novels that changed the world

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    The role of women in political participation

    The role of women in political participation

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    • Media Research
    • Culture & Human building
    • Thought
    • Literature & Art
    • Cinema
  • Kurds In Others Eyes
    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Northern Iraq

    Northern Iraq

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

  • Interview
    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

  • Home
  • Opinions
    The Impact of China’s Belt and Road Initiative on the Kurdistan Region: Opportunities and Challenges

    The Impact of China’s Belt and Road Initiative on the Kurdistan Region: Opportunities and Challenges

    From Threat to Real War: The Iran–Israel Conflict and Kurdistan’s Strategic dilemma

    From Threat to Real War: The Iran–Israel Conflict and Kurdistan’s Strategic dilemma

    Three-dimensional reaction

    Three-dimensional reaction

  • Analysis
    From Sword to Drone

    From Sword to Drone

    Word and Power

    Word and Power

    The most prominent US military bases in the Middle East

    The most prominent US military bases in the Middle East

    The fiftieth session of G7; Consequences and challenges

    The fiftieth session of G7; Consequences and challenges

    Kurdish Cause in the Middle East seems Positive

    Kurdish Cause in the Middle East seems Positive

    The Right of the Kurdistan Region to Own and Manage the Energy Sector

    The Right of the Kurdistan Region to Own and Manage the Energy Sector

    Trumpism and the wave of return to the nation-state

    Trumpism and the wave of return to the nation-state

    Iraqi Arab Summit; Identity problems between ethnic and religious depths

    Iraqi Arab Summit; Identity problems between ethnic and religious depths

    Iraq is the land of dictators and the land of mass graves

    Iraq is the land of dictators and the land of mass graves

  • Economy
    The Influence of Kurdish Rugs, Textiles, and Jewelry in International Markets and Their Representation of Cultural Identity

    The Influence of Kurdish Rugs, Textiles, and Jewelry in International Markets and Their Representation of Cultural Identity

    Economics and Mental Health

    Economics and Mental Health

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    Challenges and opportunities of teleworking in human resource management

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part Two and Final

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    A Brief on Primary Measurement Economics: Part One

    An autonomous car

    An autonomous car

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Significance and impact of tourism and agriculture on the Kurdistan Region

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    Most Notable World events of 2023

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

    China’s economic strategy in a complex and unstable world

  • Nation & State building
    Tobzawa Millie Camp of Anfal Victims

    Tobzawa Millie Camp of Anfal Victims

    In a memory of the Sykes-Picot Agreement and destiny of Kurds

    In a memory of the Sykes-Picot Agreement and destiny of Kurds

    A Brief History of NuRoj, Kurdish New Year — Newroz: second and final part

    Spiritual Revival of the Forgotten Traditions of NuRoj- Part One

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Iran and the Kurdish language

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    Reasons and motives for the British to come to Kurdistan before World War I

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the mother tongue and the dangers of foreign language domination

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    The importance of the referendum and the desire for Kurdistan’s independence

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

    On the margins of the 101st anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne

  • National Security
    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Which comes first, human rights or legal agreements?

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Compare Iraq with Ukraine

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Populism: A term used too much, less Understanding

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (3) Last part

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of political opposition in Kurdistan region (2)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Frameworks and legal principles of Political Opposition in Kurdistan Region (1)

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Tighten the sanction on Iran and its Effects on the Kurdistan Region

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Water Crisis Solution in International Law

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

    Intelligence Games – Mossad (007) operation as an example

  • Soft Power
    • All
    • Cinema
    • Culture and Human building
    • Literature and Art
    • Thought
    Word and Power

    Word and Power

    Historical Sociology

    Historical Sociology

    Can a historian be impartial?

    Can a historian be impartial?

    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    Outcomes of unhealthy education

    9 novels that changed the world

    9 novels that changed the world

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    Democracy and Prerequisites

    The role of women in political participation

    The role of women in political participation

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    A brief summary about the rise of philosophical schools in China

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    Happiness, Money, and Giving It Away

    • Media Research
    • Culture & Human building
    • Thought
    • Literature & Art
    • Cinema
  • Kurds In Others Eyes
    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Alexander Dogin and the Importance of Nation

    Northern Iraq

    Northern Iraq

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Kurds are my brothers

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    The Moogs Median Revolution in the Herodotus Narrations

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurds as the Latest Victim of the National State

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan: new state in the Middle East

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Kurdistan independence and US national security

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Later or Soon Kurdistan region will gain its independence

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

    Concerning Xaj and Siaband Epic

  • Interview
    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

    What impact do folktales have on nation-building?

Chawy Kurd
No Result
View All Result
Home Analysis

Islamic Social Movements

Translation Unit by Translation Unit
February 4, 2023
in Analysis
0 0
A A
Islamic Social Movements
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
0 0
A A

A comparison of different contemporary Islamic social movements shows that they are Janus-faced. That is, on the one hand they are modern and socially and politically “progressive” and express yearnings for democracy and economic development; on the other hand they are conservative and “authoritarian,” calling for a strict moral-religious code in society.

Consequently, tension is an inherent characteristic of most Islamic social movements. Ironically, this tension between “progressive” and “authoritarian” aspects of religious movements is the source of religious innovation. Unfortunately, many scholars of Islam fail to see the complex nature of modern Islamic social movements and seek to explain them according to textual (essentialist) or economic reductionist (contextualist) readings of Islam. This book challenges such interpretations, arguing instead that, by embracing certain opportunity spaces within the public sphere, Islamic movements could become a motivating force for economic expansion, democratization, and the popular acceptance of many aspects of modernity.

I believe that a third approach, that of the constructivists, offers a sounder and more nuanced theoretical framework to analyze the formation of Islamic political identity in contemporary Islamic movements. Thus I use the constructivist approach to differentiate opportunity spaces from the political opportunity structure and then examine the way Muslims have utilized these spaces to make demands for political, social, and economic inclusion, in addition to justice. Specially, by reexamining the interplay between the governmental policies of Turkey and societal resistance, I have been able to introduce a new typology of Islamic social movements based on the expansion and shrinking of opportunity spaces.

Approaches to the Study of Political Islam

 

 

There are three main theoretical currents in the study of religion and politics: essentialist, conceptualist, and constructivist.1 Interactions between these three approaches have been multifarious and by no means always contextual. By setting up these categories, I am aware that I slight subtle distinctions and simplify profound analyses of particular cases. However, in order to organize the vast body of social science literature on this subject, it is useful to demarcate these three broad conceptual categories.

Essentialism: The “Text” and Political Developments

 

 

Essentialism seeks to reduce the diverse spectrum of human relations to a few “essential” causes and to identify certain defining traits and texts as keys to understanding a particular religious or cultural community.2 This tendency, which can be seen in the textualism of Bernard Lewis, played a dominant role in the formation of modernization theory and the “cluster of absences” long noted by development specialists. Tradition and modernity were counterpoised, and it was axiomatic for modernization theorists to view tradition as the main culprit standing in the way of “progress.” The focus on the textual sources of Islamic revivalism in much of contemporary scholarship implies that Muslims do not reimagine and rearticulate what it means to be a Muslim in rapidly developing societies but only act on fixed Islamic principles. Lewis, for example, argues that Islam is a fixed and enduring tradition and cultural system.3 Bassam Tibi’s book Islam and the Cultural Accommodation of Social Changeis another example of this tendency to fix a purported Islamic essence; Tibi argues that “Islam” is a set of fixed texts, doctrines, and practices by which a Muslim sense of self is determined.4 Religious discourse, for Tibi, seemingly is produced in a vacuum, hermetically sealed from changing contexts and interpretations. In the end, he creates a model of a homo Islamicus who is ahistorical and similar to a fundamentalist caricature of “true” Islam. The essentialists attribute agency to Islam as an institution and as a set of fixed doctrines but negate the interactive agency of Muslims themselves. Tibi, for example, concludes that political Islam “provides no innovative prospects for the future but is solely a vision of the future as a restoration of the past. . . . Political Islam may therefore—with some restrictions—be interpreted as a backward-oriented utopia.”5 Lewis, like Tibi, has tended to assume that “Islam rather than any other element is the ultimate basis of identity, of loyalty, of authority.”6 Islamic identity is viewed as being a primordial, essentially political, all-encompassing, and determining force.7 Similarly, Emmanuel Sivan claims that “Islamic revival—while activist and militant—is thus essentially defensive; a sort of holding operation against modernity.” Sivan sees the problem in the antimodern nature of Islam and concludes that Islamic groups are “all united by intense hatred of the ‘evil of evils,’ modernity. Modernity is inherently alien to Islam.”

Lewis, Tibi, and Sivan have exaggerated the impact of Islamic doctrine on the conduct of individuals and on the patterns of institutions in society as a whole. In addition to their problematic approach to the issue of agency, they tend to argue that there is a fixed political language and idiom in Islam that guides Muslim conduct in the public sphere. Thus essentialist scholars have treated diverse and competing Islamic movements as homogenous ideological movements that primarily are influenced by the Qur’an and the writings of certain individuals such as Abu’l al-Ala Mawdudi (1903–1979), Sayyid Qutb (1906–1964), Hasan al-Banna (1906–1949), and Muhammad Husayn Fadlallah (1935–).10 This approach maintains that all contemporary Islamic social and political movements are motivated and guided by an Islamic worldview. One aim of this book is to show that the diversity of Muslim beliefs and practices is not compatible with an analysis that regards a monolithic, consistent, and unchanging “Islam” as the foundation of all social and political movements that call themselves Islamic.

 

 

Furthermore, by employing an ethnocentric and teleological definition of modernity, such scholars essentially are claiming that Muslim societies are inherently traditional and unable to modernize. In fact, some scholars of modernization have attributed the failure of democratization and capitalism in Muslim societies to a certain “cluster of absences, a missing middle class, the missing city, the absence of political rights.”11 Daniel P. Lerner, for example, argued that Islam was a traditional ideology, reacting to the processes of modernization, and that in the case of Turkey it forced the country to choose between “Mecca and mechanization.”12 Turkish scholars, no doubt influenced by the affinities of this approach with the Kemalist state ideology of Comtean positivism, have internalized Lerner’s framework in their studies of political development in their own country.13 They, as well as a number of Western scholars, have tended to treat the Islamic movement as a reactionary force fighting a vain rearguard action against the processes of Westernization and secularization. These theories tend to explain human conduct in terms of simplistic dichotomies, modern and traditional, while ignoring the causal mechanisms that influence the evolution of Islamic movements, economic expansion, popular imagination, and social change.

Modernization theory dominated the social science research on Turkey, and explicit assumptions about old versus new, tradition versus modernity, religion versus secularism, the inexorable march toward Westernization, and sociopolitical reactions being religious fanaticism informed these studies. They presented the establishment of the Republican regime as the inevitable “emergence of modern Turkey” and depicted its founding Kemalist ideology as the fulfillment of destiny for the modernizing forces. This teleological, state-centric, and structuralist reading of the Turkish polity and society ignored the destruction of the Anatolian mosaic of Armenians, Assyrians, Greeks, Kurds, and other ethnic and religious groups. Tar1k Z. Tunaya, Niyazi Berkes, and Bernard Lewis set the framework of Turkish studies in terms of “discovering” Turkish nationalism as a primordial identity that was awakened by Mustafa Kemal through his policies of progressive secularism that cleansed this identity of its Islamic-Ottoman layers. These writers all focused on the history of ideas and treated the state as a positive agent to put “modernity” into practice. Their understanding of the state as a progressive force informed their analyses of societal reactions, which they treated as “Muslim fanaticism.” In addition, their works ignored the deep ethnic and religious cleavages in Turkish society and the state violence periodically employed to suppress identity claims. Only the new generation of scholars has oVered a more nuanced reading of the state-society relations (Nilüfer Göle, Re7at Kasaba, 6erif Mardin, Robert Olson, and Martin van Bruinessen).15 We need a more nuanced and theoretically sophisticated understanding of the processes by which religious and ethnic identities become politicized in response to economic and political problems in modern societies such as that of contemporary Turkey.

 

 

M. HAKAN YAVUZ

Previous Post

Why America Can’t Build Allied Armies

Next Post

The future of political philosophy

Translation Unit

Translation Unit

The translation unit of Chawy Kurd center for political developments include of several expert translators from international languages who translate articles into Kurdish.

Related Posts

From Sword to Drone
Analysis

From Sword to Drone

July 11, 2025
2
Word and Power
Analysis

Word and Power

July 4, 2025
14
The most prominent US military bases in the Middle East
Analysis

The most prominent US military bases in the Middle East

July 4, 2025
8

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

February 2023
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728  
« Jan   Mar »

Aa

0 0
A A
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advisors Board
  • Sponsors Board

2024 - 2022 © CHKurd - WordPress theme by ChawyKurd

No Result
View All Result
  • کوردی
  • Home
  • Opinions
  • Analysis
  • Economy
  • Nation & State building
  • National Security
  • Soft Power
    • Media Research
    • Culture & Human building
    • Thought
    • Literature & Art
    • Cinema
  • Kurds In Others Eyes
  • Interview

2024 - 2022 © CHKurd - WordPress theme by ChawyKurd

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

- Select Visibility -